| STILLWATER PONY ALL-STATE TEAM | ||
| 1975 | Kevin Meinke | Minnesota Morris-Basketball |
| 1977 | Chris Engler | Wyoming-Basketball |
| 1980 | Mark Wandemacher | Carleton College-Basketball |
| 1988 | Jeff Nelson | Iowa-Football |
| 1989 | Daren Danielson | Air Force Academy-Football |
| STILLWATER PONY ACADEMIC ALL-STATE TEAM | ||
| 1993 | Kevin Klancher | North Dakota-Football |
| 2005 | Kevin Gullikson | U of Wisconsin-Basketball |
| 2005 | Andrew Gilmore | Illinois Wesleyan-Basketball |
| 2008 | Joel Armstrong | Winona State-Basketball |
| 2013 | Andrew Duxbury | UW-Eau Claire-Basketball |
| STILLWATER PONY ALL-METRO TEAM | ||
| 1975 | Kevin Meinke | |
| 1976 | Bob Bliss | |
| 1977 | Chris Engler | |
| 1980 | Mark Wandemacher | |
| 1981 | Bob Samuelson | |
| 1982 | Todd Thatcher | |
| 1987 | Keith Newman | |
| 1989 | Daren Danielson | |
| 2023 | Max Shikenjanski | |
| STILLWATER PONY MBCA SENIOR ALL STAR GAME | ||
| 2002 | Josh Matel | |
| 2004 | Andrew Boldt | |
| 2005 | Kevin Gullikson | |
| 2005 | Andrew Gilmore | |
| 2006 | Eric Hostetter | |
| 2008 | Joel Armstrong | |
| 2015 | Matt Anderson | |
| 2023 | Max Shikenjanski | |